Norway Joins France’s Nuclear Umbrella
Watch or listen, then answer the open questions in order. The key words are signals you will hear in the broadcast — listen for them to locate the answer.
Key words
nuclear umbrella · nuclear protection · the start of talks
1. What did the Norwegian Prime Minister and the French President announce?
Show answer
They announced the start of talks for Norway to join the group of countries coming under France’s nuclear protection — that is, the French nuclear umbrella.
Key words
nuclear arsenal · to coordinate its deterrent
2. Which countries are already part of the plan, and why did the UK join?
Show answer
The plan already includes Germany, Poland, the Netherlands, Belgium, Greece, Sweden, Denmark and the UK. The UK is the only other European country with a nuclear arsenal, and it joined as a way to coordinate its deterrent with its closest neighbour.
Key words
growing concerns · commitment
3. What broader argument does France make about European security?
Show answer
France says Europe needs to take greater responsibility for its own security, amid growing concerns over the commitment of the United States to Europe’s defence.
Key words
exclusively linked · deterrence against military threats
4. According to the Norwegian Prime Minister, what is changing about France’s nuclear policy, and what does Norway want?
Show answer
For many years French nuclear weapons were exclusively linked to France’s own security. France is now opening up dialogue with close allies on how its nuclear weapons can also contribute to European security and deterrence against military threats. Norway wants to be part of that dialogue, alongside its Nordic neighbours and partners like the UK, Germany and Poland.
Key words
sensitive · nuclear profile
5. Why does the correspondent find it more interesting to ask why Norway didn’t sign up earlier?
Show answer
Norway is the European country closest to the largest nuclear arsenal in the world — Russia’s, in the Kola Peninsula, just 60 miles from Norway. The issue is therefore very sensitive there: Norway has not wanted a nuclear profile, which is why it took longer to sign up.
Key words
the backstop · threat in both directions
6. Beyond the Russian threat, what unspoken concern is driving Norway’s shift?
Show answer
There are worries that US nuclear capability — which has been the backstop of NATO’s security guarantees since the alliance began — is no longer so certain, with allies unsure whether the Americans would really come to the defence of a European ally in case of attack. Norway is therefore worried about the threat in both directions.
Key words
legislation · to host nuclear weapons · pre-positioned · the deterrence initiative
7. What does the new agreement specifically NOT involve, and how does this differ from the existing NATO nuclear umbrella?
Show answer
It does not involve hosting nuclear weapons — Norwegian legislation says Norway will not host nuclear weapons, and the Prime Minister was clear that does not change. None of the European countries signed up to the deterrence initiative want to host them. This contrasts with the NATO nuclear umbrella, under which US nuclear weapons are pre-positioned in several European countries.
Key words
to temporarily deploy · nuclear-capable aircraft · to increase exercises · to coordinate intelligence
8. What concrete steps will the French initiative involve, and why is this a major shift for France?
Show answer
France will temporarily deploy nuclear-capable aircraft to some of these countries, so they would be ready to move in case of a nuclear incident or attack. They will also increase exercises and coordinate more intelligence. This is a major shift because, until now, France’s nuclear deterrent sat alone — it was not extended to other countries. President Macron announced this change on 2 March.
Key words
to give away security influence · self-sufficient · pro-US · change of tone
9. Does the correspondent think the US is losing security influence in Europe? Why is Norway particularly interesting in this regard?
Show answer
She says the US has actively been trying to give away its security influence — it wants Europe to become more self-sufficient. Norway is interesting because it is one of the most pro-US countries in NATO and has always called the US its most important security partner (as has Denmark, which also joined). So Norway’s move represents a real change of tone, although the US would only welcome Europe being more self-sufficient.
Key words
on the record / off the record · to put into question · nuclear guarantees
10. Despite the uncertainty, what important caveat does the correspondent add about the official US position?
Show answer
All the conversations — on the record and off the record — say that the US has not put into question its nuclear guarantees for Europe. So although there is concern about American reliability, Washington has not formally withdrawn its nuclear commitment.
Key words
to become a target · de rigueur · to boost security · imminent threat
11. How did Russia react to the French initiative, and how seriously do European countries take that reaction?
Show answer
Russia has not reacted to the Norwegian announcement, but when the French initiative was first made in early March, Russia said any country willing to host nuclear-capable aircraft would itself become a target. The correspondent says this is de rigueur for the Russian government — they say it about any European move to boost security — so it’s not surprising, and the countries involved do not see it as an imminent threat.
Key words
to boost its nuclear arsenal · tied up in Ukraine · to test NATO’s will · a potential nuclear attack
12. What concern has Norway itself raised in recent months about Russia?
Show answer
Norway has said that it sees Russia boosting its nuclear arsenal, even while tied up in Ukraine. It is very concerned that Russia may be preparing to test NATO’s will when it comes to nuclear weapons and a potential nuclear attack.